Cherry Ice Cream Recipe
July 9, 2005 | by Heidi | Filed under Dessert Recipes
Two cherry ice cream recipes - one from the Batch family, one from me. I'm sitting here with my mouth stained red, and my fingers purple. My teeth, lips, fingernails, and cuticles all look like I've been hanging out in someone's berry patch. The tiny red splatters on my cheeks add a nice touch as well. I don't know what to say - It isn't everyday that you get a 5-pound box of the worlds most perfect Bing cherries delivered to your front door. Five pounds of perfect cherries, and not a bad one in the lot - I looked!
The cherries came from family-run Batch's Best Fruit in Manson, Washington and they are only available for a few short weeks each year. You may have read about these cherries in past issues of Saveur and Bon Appetit and I'm telling you - forget sending flowers or chocolates the next time you are in the dog house, send cherries. I laughed when Greg Batch told me he had a daughter named Ruby - of course he does.
The Batch orchard is located on a high bench in the hills above Lake Chelan, 350 miles from the nearest city. The elevation and the 55-mile long, 1500-foot deep lake create a unique micro-climate, and warm days and cool nights equal cherries that are crunchier and sweeter than most. Every single cherry is picked by hand from their small orchard of twelve acres. The cherries are very fragile so they have to be picked in a short time and handled gently. Freshly picked cherries are carefully placed in foam-lined buckets(!), and shipped later that same day. The harvest day starts at 5 a.m., when there is just enough light to see. Cherries are picked until around noon, because as the sun gets hotter, the cherries get softer....and well, that can be messy. Before packing, the Batch crew drenches the cherries in water from Lake Chelan and cools the cherries to 34 degrees. This quick chill - again, helps to keep the cherries desirably crisp and juicy. They are sorted, packed, boxed and shipped.

I received one of their last shipments of Bing's. The Lapins ship next week, and if you are quick, there is still time to get onboard with the Sweethearts (they will be taking orders until this Thursday, the 14th). These cherries have nothing in common with supermarket fruits that have been picked long before their prime - before the natural sweetness of the fruit has been allowed to develop. If you've only ever tasted is a mass market cherry, treat yourself to a box of these - it will change the way you think about these plump, little, red gems.
I asked Greg if there were any interesting factoids he could tell this city girl about growing cherries, eating cherries, or living a life amongst cherries. One funny thing he told me was that when it rains, they really worry. If cherries that are nearly ripe get too wet, water settles in the bowl around the stem. Too much water will cause them to split. To dry the trees after a rain - get this....they contract with a helicopter pilot who flies slowly over the orchard to dry the trees. Fortunately it doesn't rain too much in Eastern Washington, so it is good cherry-growing country.
The dreaded cherry stain is also no match for the Batch family, and they tipped me off to their secret stain-stripping ingredient. To get cherry stains out of cotton shirts, soak the stain in cold water, then wring out. Squeeze fresh lemon juice directly on it and let it sit for 30 minutes. Wash as usual.
While many people have robust farmer's markets in their communities, others don't. Even if you have a farmer's market or road-side farm stand(s) in your community you may not have the SELECTION of locally grown produce that you are after. Not everyone can get cherries locally. One of the coolest things about small growers utilizing the reach of the internet is it gives people the option to still buy beautiful, farm-direct produce even if they can't get say cherries, citrus, etc, farm-direct in their own communities.
So, what to do with 5 pounds of perfect cherries? We ate a pound, I took a pound to share with friends when I went out yesterday, I'm saving a pound (or so) for tomorrow when I will need them to lure people to the garage sale we are having. I used some of the remainder to make cherry ice cream. Coincidentally, Greg Batch and his family have also been busy making cherry ice cream up in Washington, and he was nice enough to share his family recipe with me as well. I'll include both recipes below.
If you want to win someone over big-time, or if you just want to treat yourself - it's not too late to place an cherry order. I'll let you know down the line when more of Batch's Best is available.
Batch Family Mountain Cherry Choconut Ice Cream
1 1/2 cups sliced Bing, Lapin or Sweetheart cherries
1 pint whipping cream
1 pint half and half
2 egg yolks (hs note: to eliminate risk of food poisoning from raw eggs, use pasteurized eggs product for this recipe)
1/2 cup white sugar
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1/2 cup chopped raw almonds
1/2 cup shaved dark chocolate (or to taste)
Whisk whipping cream, half and half, egg yolks, sugar and vanilla in a mixing bowl until sugar is dissolved. Add cherries and stir. Chill mixture for 30 minutes in freezer. Pour into ice cream maker canister. Run machine until mixture reaches milkshake consistency. Add almonds and chocolate and mix until they're incorporated. Continue running machine until ice cream reaches desired consistency.
My Basic Cherry Ice Cream
This ice-cream isn't overly sweet and is packed with big. juicy cherry chunks. It has a honey finish and tastes best the same day it is made.
2 cups heavy cream
1 cup whole milk
1/4 cup honey (light flavored honey is best for this recipe)
3/4 pounds Bing, Lapin, or Sweetheart cherries, pitted and torn into chunks
3 tablespoons cherry liquor or cherry brandy or Amaretto
Place cream, milk, and honey in a medium saucepan. Stir to dissolve the honey. Heat over low to moderate heat, stirring from time to time, until tiny bubbles form around the edges of the pan. Be careful not to heat to a full-out boil.
Remove from the heat and let cool for 5 minutes. Add the chopped cherries and liquor. Cover and refrigerate until completely chilled. Don't skimp here or your ice-cream might not set up.
Stir the mixture again to blend and transfer it to an ice cream maker. Freeze according to manufacturer's instructions and eat the same day.
Makes 1 quart.
Never miss a recipe!
Enter your email address to subscribe to 101 Cookbooks via email:
Your Comments
Perfect timing. I was thinking about making ice cream - fresh peaches were luring me. But cherry is a favorite and the temptation of fresh farm grown is too irresistible. Thanks for sharing all this great info!
Can't wait to try the ice cream...I raved about 101 Cookbooks on my blog but didn't see that you had trackbacks.
Marianne
wow this is a beautiful ode to an amazing cherry. but wait, what have you done with the noyau? this flavour could have been a stand-in for the liqueur, or you could make your own from it!
Dammit, I have TOTALLY been trying to make cherry ice cream for 2 weeks, but I get to the market too late for cherries.
What a lovely article. I wish I lived in the USA so that I could order some of those beautiful cherries. Your article is inspiring.
These cherries sound amazing! I don't dare hope they'd ship to Canada, although we do get excellent cherries from BC. You won't mind, will you, if I forward your equally amazing article to my daughter, a cherry lover from very early childhood. She would hang a pair over each ear: et voila earrings!
Very nice post!
Okay, this looks delicious! That photo is beautiful and has my mouth watering. We are terrible ice cream makers, have used (and returned) almost every established and new-fangled icre cream maker brand with no results. Just looking at that picture, though, is satisfying.
Great post. So much interesting information. Love the part about the helicopter!
Great post! With the abundance of great cherries at the Paris markets, I've been making clafoutis. I've never made it before, but it's so easy and rewarding, I've become the clafoutis queen. And the best part: You don't have to pit the cherries!
This looks like Barbie's ice cream! Like Lisa, I am a big big fan of cherry clafoutis, I used to make them with my parents' cherries, and I still make them to remember my childhood.
wonderful post and great picture - i'm off to get some cherries!!
How, I relate - I made a cherry clafouti in a paella pan last night - a rather large clafouti - following Julia's recipe. My my fingers are stained, but the kitchen is not longer splattered. The pitter from WS was quite handy, though I was positive an old one was stuffed some place . . . But, I really want to try the Lello gelato maker! Maybe by high peach season!
CREAM-MORE CREAM,UM UM GOOD...
"This is the best"
Have you ever had Olsen's Cherries from Sunnyvale?
I've had Olsen's cherries!! Still have a huge jar of Queen Annes marinating in vodka in the fridge. I was so lucky as to have lunch with Deborah Olsen and her daddy once.
I came home yesterday with a pound of Bings from the Santa Monica Farmer's Market here in LA. I'm thinking of trying the Batch's ice cream recipe -- is it true, though, that the egg/milk/sugar mixture isn't cooked before freezing? I've never seen a raw egg ice cream recipe before!
I can't wait to try it. Being from Canada though Batch's are not an option, I do however have some deliciously sweet BC cherries in the fridge right now. Thanks for the idea.
Just made a batch of "modified" Cherry Garcia icecream. Cooked custard base with vanilla bean, etc. I used single bean 71% dark chocolate from Peru, and added lightly toasted Pinion nuts. I wanted a really intense color and cherry flavor in the icecream itself so I made a cherry juice reduction from bing cherry juice, Cherry Herring liqueur and cherry extract in 35% alcohol. This was reduced to a thick syrup after flaming off the alcohol at about 1/3 the original volume. Turned out great except for one problem. The pitted and halved bing cherries, even though poached until soft, still were a bit icy after freezing. How can I avoid this?
C - My guess right off the bat is that when you poached the cherries they took on more liquid. That liquid probably turned to ice when you went to freeze the ice cream. I didn't have that problem when I used the chopped cherries in their natural state.
Also, your freezer might be too cold. Was the consistency of your ice cream over all ok? Or was it hard as a rock?
Heidi,
I suppose the icecream was pretty hard all right. When I made an earlier version with just fresh cherries the freezing problem was worse so poaching helped some. Also, I made a version with dried bing cherries and then there was no frozen cherry problem at all but it went against my grain not to use fresh cherries.


