Black Sticky Gingerbread Recipe

December 4, 2005    |   31 Comments

Everyone needs a fail-proof gingerbread recipe in their repertoire, this is it. With a new tree in my care, and a drawer full of colorful holiday bulbs itching for an audience, I decided it was time to dial up the holiday spirit. I tied a couple dozen little ornaments to my tree with short pieces of string, and then gave my tree a nice drink of water. When I was done I turned my attention to the quest for a serious gingerbread recipe.
Almost immediately, Regan Daley's In the Sweet Kitchen caught my eye. Flipped to the index...D....E...F.....Gingerbread, Black Sticky. I'll take it.

The Black Sticky Gingerbread comes together like the cake that it is - straight-forward, unfussy, with a bit of kick and attitude. Melt the butter with the sweeteners, stir in a few eggs, fold in the fragrant spices and flour, spike it with some freshly grated ginger, and pour the batter into the prepared pan. I decided to make little, individual cakes instead of using the loaf pan described in the recipe, which posed a small problem. I ended up over-filling the tins - let's just say I was happy I placed all the little cake tins on a baking sheet. If you do alternative sized versions of this recipe don't fill the pans more than 1/2 to 2/3 full. 3/4 was too much.

The cake is outrageously dark, dense, flavorful, and delicious. Not the prettiest cake you'll ever make, but it might be one of the tastiest. The burnt-caramel-esque crust that forms on the top of the cake is outrageous. That was the first part of the cake to go. If you make mini-loafs with it you can wrap it in wax paper, and then in natural colored kraft paper, or vintage wall paper with a ribbon for a nice party favor or hostess gift this time of year. I think this is the best gingerbread cake I've tasted. Think you've come across one that is tastier? Post a link with a description in the comments.

For those of you not familiar with Regan's book (particularly those of you who love to bake, or make sweets), it is well worth it to look into this heavyweight. The book tops out near 700-pages, with half the of the pages dedicated to thoughtful, well-tested, detailed recipes. The second half delivers an impressive block of reference material ranging from troubleshooting charts and garnishing guides to in-depth descriptions about all different types sweet-friendly ingredients. Need third-party validation? It was an IACP Book of the Year award winner.

Black Sticky Gingerbread Recipe

HS note: Just a quick mention that I like Wholesome Sweetners brand Organic Molasses, it is an unsulphered organic, blackstrap molasses.

1 cup unsalted butter
1/2 cup water
3/4 cup unsulphured blackstrap molasses
3/4 cup flavourful honey, such as a dark wildflower, berry or chestnut
1 cup tightly packed dark brown sugar
3 cups all-purpose flour
1 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons ground ginger
2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon allspice
1/8 teaspoon ground cloves
3 large eggs, at room temperature
1/2 cup partly skimmed milk (2%)
1 packed tablespoon grated fresh ginger root

Lightly sweetened whipped cream, to serve

1. Preheat the oven to 325. Lightly grease a 9 x 9 x 2-inch baking pan and line the bottom with a piece of parchment paper that has been cut to hang over two opposite edges by a couple of inches. This overhang will make removing the cake from the pan clean and simple.

2. Combine the butter, water, molasses, honey and brown sugar in a medium non-reactive saucepan and place over low heat. Stir the mixture frequently until the butter is melted, and all of the ingredients are well blended. Remove from the heat, pour into a large bowl and set aside to cool.

3. Meanwhile, sift together the flour, baking soda, salt, ginger, cinnamon, all-spice and cloves, and set aside. When the molasses mixture feels just warm to the touch, add the eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Add the milk and stir to combine. Fold the dry ingredients into the batter in four additions, using big, long strokes. Don't be concerned if you can't get all the lumps out-settle for most of them! Stir in the grated ginger.

4. Pour the batter into the prepared pan and bake in the centre of the oven for 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 hours, or until the top of the cake springs back when touched and a cake tester inserted into the centre comes out clean. Allow to cool for 15 minutes, then, using the overhang of parchment, lift the cake out of the pan and cool completely on a wire rack before cutting. Well-wrapped in plastic, this gingerbread actually improves with age. If stored at room temperature, it will have a sponge-cakey texture and will keep for about 4 days. Refrigerated, it becomes stickier, denser and wonderfully chewy and will last at least a week. Allow the cake to return to room temperature before serving. This cake is fabulous warm, and the only adornment it needs is mounds of softly whipped cream.

Serves 10 to 12.

Print Recipe


Your Comments


cookiecrumb
December 4, 2005

Oh, now that you're a horticulturalist, I think you should try a Meyer lemon tree! I confess, my second year with mine has not been successful, but at least it's still alive and still in a pot on the patio. I think you can even grow them indoors. (In front of a sunny window.) The blossoms smell divine.

 

Heidi
December 4, 2005

You won't believe this. I was done writing this post earlier today and in the car with my friends. One of my friends, Yong had a little Meyer lemon tree that wasn't getting enough sun in her apartment so she wanted to know if one of us would adopt it. So I did! It is sitting on my kitchen counter right now.

Somehow in less than a week I've now taken on not one, but two trees.

I'll keep you all posted on their progess. Any pointers are welcome. -h

 

blintz
December 4, 2005

oh heidi you are indeed a girl after my own heart, and black thumb. i can't grow a plant (or keep a plant growing) to save my life. most recent victim: cute little basil plant from the farmer's market. dead. dry. gone.
and i do love the idea of the burnt carmel-esque pieces from black sticky gingerbread....yeah! i'm going to post a reworked martha cookie: simple gingersnaps with raspberry jam. so good!

 

s'kat
December 4, 2005

You know, I completely understand where you are coming from. I've owned books on plants and herbs my entire life; I even ended up married to a horticulturist.

Any chance that I could keep a plant alive without him around? Lol- not so much so!

Good luck with the two new additions to your home. Hopefully, this time around, you'll receive so many good vibes that the plants will thrive and grow voraciously.

Oh, and the gingerbread sounds quite enchanting, too! Such sticky goodness.

 

Nic
December 4, 2005

Oh, congrats on the Meyer lemon tree, Heidi. I'm consideing adding one to my garden, myself.
I just adore gingerbread. In the Sweet Kitchen isn't in my collection yet, but I'm keeping my fingers crossed for Christmas.

 

Lorraine Peltier
December 5, 2005

I have a black thumb too - I am happy to be in such good company - lol! I am thinking of making this Black Sticky Gingerbread for my neighbours as part of their Christmas gift. They laugh at my black thumb; if they see me with a new plant, I have to suffer through many good-natured jokes about how long will it take me to kill it etc. But they have never compained about my cooking!

 

Fran
December 5, 2005

Love gingerbread and this sounds delicious. I think I will use mesquite honey, which is very tasty. Good luck with the trees!

 

Jessica
December 5, 2005

Heidi,

I'm so happy to see a post about Regan Daley's Book! In the Sweet Kitchen is one of my most cherished cookbooks. Her recipes have never failed to delight me- I actually made the Pecan Caramel Sandwich cookies from her book this weekend, and they were delicious.

Thanks for the inspiration and tips, as always.

 

Misha
December 5, 2005

This recipe sounds great! I swear by Nigella Lawson's recipe, but have also been a bit put off by the use of corn syrup which I was willing to tolerate being sure it accounted entirely for the moistness. If this recipe compares then I''ll be SO happy to ban the Caros!

 

Rachel
December 5, 2005

Heidi...
This recipe looks great! Especially because my husband loves gingerbread, molasses, shoefly pie and the list with ginger and/or molasses goes on. A couple of times a year my husband's side of the family gets together and we usually have some sort of homemade applesauce cake or stollen bread... the last time we had some sort of chocolate upside down cake that has been in the family for 20 some years- I love cake and most baked goods (how could you not!) but I hated it! So maybe I will use this recipe and start a new traditional cake! Sounds delicious!

 

Cate
December 5, 2005

Speaking of lemons, try serving gingerbread with lemon curd instead of whipped cream. Heaven!

 

cookiecrumb
December 5, 2005

OK, well... pointers on growing lemons. I've learned that they like water and fertilizer. But I was mistaken about *how much* water they like, and may have been overdoing it.
Sloat Gardens sells a marvelous fertilizer in a little (1-quart-size) plastic canister, called MaxSea, that's very good. At $10, it's also very pricey, but one can will last you at least two years.
Good luck with your trees! I'm thinking about a bay (laurel) tree next.

 

vanessa
December 5, 2005

I've always had a soft spot for liquid sweetness. Even that sulphuric blackstrap molasses. That's a comfort flavor right there.
The color matches my thumb, so I empathize.

I kill mint. Really.

 

Faith
December 6, 2005

I can hardly wait to try this recipe! I love gingerbread so much. I made Nigella Lawson's gingerbread cake last year, but that is a little lighter, using fresh ginger.

Also, I made Regan Daley's Sticky Spiked Double-Apple Cake with a Brown Sugar-Brandy Sauce twice this month, and it is ridiculously, preposterously good. I've never made anything so universally acclaimed; people were climbing over each other for it. It's boozy and fruity enough to serve as holiday fruitcake, and gets even better when it sits a couple days before serving. I want to eat it for breakfast like she suggests, but there's never any left!

http://www.chefadventures.com/v1/recipes/2001/december/doubleapplecake.htm

 

shauna
December 6, 2005

This sounds just scrumptious. And I'm pretty sure I could convert it to gluten-free flour fairly easily. This may be another holiday treat in the making.

I have only one plant, and some of the leaves are looking just a touch sickly. But, I've managed to keep it alive since April, an unheard of feat around here!

 

Luisa
December 6, 2005

I'm so glad that you like In the Sweet Kitchen, too, as it's among my favorite baking books. I haven't gotten around to trying most of the recipes I want to, so I'm glad to read here in the comments about ones I should be paying special attention to! As for gingerbread, I'm not sure if I have a recipe to Daley's, but if you've never had David Lebovitz's Fresh Ginger Cake, you must try it now. I first read about it on Epicurious 4 or 5 years ago. It's splendid. As is his blog!

 

brian
December 6, 2005

SCORE! everyone forgot all about the plate of this you left in my kitchen, in all the craziness of the huge cooking night.

so i have been snacking on it greedily, the whole plate, it's all mine! muahahaha!

(it's delicious - thanks!)

 

Sarah
December 7, 2005

So I made this last night. It went over very well. I made a couple of changes due to being vegan. It wasn't as sticky, which I think is due to the egg replacement.

 

johanna
December 7, 2005

The black sticky ginger bread sound really good. I got really inspired reading about it. Thanks for having my glögg on your daily links today.

 

joseph duemer
December 8, 2005

You guys ought to give plants a serious try. I am currently overwintering a big pot of lemongrass & a couple of bunches of thyme along with two beautiful little rosemary trees. I grow lemon trees from seeds off the cutting board. It's ten degrees outside right now, but I have fresh herbs. I'm not bragging, I'm just saying there are real rewards & with most herbs you just have to give them water--they don't even like good soil. Oh, about that basil? It's an annual so it isn't going to live through the winter no matter what you do, but a few seeds in a pot in the spring will give you basil all summer long. OK, sure, I'm bragging. A little.

 

Anonymous
December 10, 2005

Are there any variations that should be made to the gingerbread recipe if I use a loaf pan? What about a round cake pan?

Thanks!

 

Elena
December 10, 2005

Along the lines of the last comment . . . what size pans did you use for the individual cakes and how long did you bake? I'd love to include minis of this recipe in my holiday goody bags.
(p.s. I'm a big fan of your book, Heidi.)

 

asdfdsa
December 12, 2005

I tried the recipe using two loaf pans and actually FORGOT to put in the baking powder. Horrifying! Or so I thought, but amazingly the recipe held up to even this abuse! It was almost inedible at first but desperation caused us to try it again the next day w/whipped cream, after leaving it wrapped in plastic at room temp as described in the recipe. It had become e a very dense almost brownie/fudge-like brick gingerbread thingy with an extra chewy edge. Surpisingly good! I"ll be trying the recipe again (*with* leavening), but maybe with half the amount of b.p. since I really liked the density of the "mistake" bread. It smells DIVINE in the oven! Thanks Heidi!

 

faith
December 12, 2005

OK - I am making these right now and man they smell good! I put them in tiny gold paper cups - they'll be mini gingerbread bites. I think they are sticking a bit; I wish I would have sprayed some bake spray in the cups first. But the recipe makes A LOT. The advantage of baking them like this is you get even more of the crispy, chewy crust. Very yummy!

 

Lulu
December 13, 2005

Heidi, I ended up leaving the gingerbread you brought over at Brian's house, and he ate it all (as he mentioned above). So I was forced to make my own. I forgot the baking soda too! But it turned out great - with a brownie-like texture, exactly what I've been looking for in gingerbread.

 

Andrea
December 14, 2005

A pan that measures 9 x 9 x 2" isn't a loaf pan.

 

Heidi
December 14, 2005

You are totally right - I don't know why I imagine all gingerbread cakes in a loaf shape. Will strike the term loaf. Thanks. -h

 

Tana
December 16, 2005

Heidi, is that you in the photo? (I should know this, but I don't recall ever seeing a picture, though surely I have.)

You are exactly as beautiful as I thought you'd be. You look thoughtful and intelligent. Whoever took the photo: lovely. Thank you.

Am I the only one who confuses Shuna with Shauna? I need to train myself: it's like confusing "Tana" with "Tanya." I get that all the time, and say, "The 'y' is silent."

Heidi, one of my little tricks is that I substitute cardamom for cloves. (My Christmas gingerbread cookie recipe is straight from Joy of Cooking, times 4 = 14 cups of flour, and no cloves.) It does add an interesting element.

 

Chef Shane
December 18, 2005

Hi,
This looks absolutely delicious. I love good gingerbread; the stickier the better. I will be giving this recipe a try over the holidays.

Merry Christmas to you all,

Chef Shane

 

Stafford
December 18, 2005

Heidi:

I've been making Claudia Fleming's Guinness Gingerbread, and it's moist, sticky and amazing. Sounds similar, but with Guinness! It's from her cookbook THE LAST COURSE and a version is also posted on the Sugar In The Raw website:
www.sugarintheraw.com/html/recipes/naturallysimple/gingerbread.html
I sprinkle it with more turbinado sugar while it's cooling, and that crunchy texture is nice.

Can't wait to try this one!
Allen

 

Jo
December 19, 2005

Well, I tried baking this in an 8x8x1 3/4" pan... came out great, but my oven needed cleaning after the overspill burnt! Those 9x9x2" pans aren't easy to come by. I like the idea of gingerbread cupcakes. Thanks for the recipe.

 

Recently on 101 Cookbooks




bottom columns

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of its User Agreement and Privacy Policy.